36.8k views
2 votes
What social commentary about communist Russia does Orwell make with this excerpt?

Russians faced many challenges and struggles working on collective farms.
Russians lacked the creative abilities to innovate solutions to problems. Russians were able to predict and avoid potential struggles.
Russians lacked knowledge of basic modern agricultural practices.

2 Answers

3 votes

Final answer:

Orwell provides social commentary on the challenges and struggles Russians faced on collective farms, the unrealistic portrayal of these efforts in Soviet propaganda, and the Communist regime's lack of foresight and adaptability in agricultural practices and innovation.

Step-by-step explanation:

George Orwell's social commentary on communist Russia, particularly through his work which is not directly mentioned but is likely to be 'Animal Farm', draws parallels between the reality of Soviet agricultural policies and the depicted struggles of the characters. In his depiction, Orwell comments on how the Russians faced many challenges working on collective farms, reflecting the resistance and suffering of the peasants due to forced collectivization and unrealistic production quotas. The portrayal underscores the lack of practical understanding of modern agricultural practices by the ruling Communist Party, as well as a void of creative abilities to innovate solutions, leading to widespread famine and hardship.

The Soviet propaganda's portrayal of collectivization as joyful contrasted starkly with the abusive and often violent imposition of these policies, as artists and writers were pressed into service to illustrate an idealized reality. The disconnect between the revolution’s promises and the peasants' grim reality is a key element of Orwell's commentary. Furthermore, the inefficiencies and hardships underscored by the challenges of achieving the utopian goals reveal the underlying critique that the Communist administration lacked the necessary foresight and adaptability to anticipate and manage the potential struggles inherent in their efforts to centralize and control agriculture.

User Po
by
4.9k points
4 votes

Answer:

A

Step-by-step explanation:

User Michael Powell
by
4.4k points