170k views
7 votes
A simple question

1. Why x/∞=0 for x real numbers. can you explain it?
2.why x/0 for x real numbers is infinity (∞)?

STOP COPY PASTE THIS IS NOT A SERIOUS QUESTION BUT BECAUSE I AM CURIOUS!
DON'T ANSWER JUST FOR A POINTS BUT TO HELP PEOPLE!​

User Infamous
by
8.4k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Neither of these statements are true.

x/∞ = 0 is a nonsensical statement. It's more accurate to say


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to\infty) \frac xy = 0

for any real number x. The important bit is that y is an arbitrarily large number as it approaches ∞. To convince yourself that this expression approaches 0 as y gets larger and larger, try fixing x and pick any increasing sequence of numbers for y.

For example, let x = 1 and take y from the sequence of increasing powers of 10, {10, 10², 10³, …}, which grows without bound. Then

1/10 = 0.1

1/10² = 0.01

1/10³ = 0.001

and so on. Naturally, the larger the power of 10 and thus the larger y gets, the closer x/y gets to 0.

Similarly, x/0 is nonsense, but the "limit-ized" version of the claim is also incorrect. For any fixed real number x, the limit


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to0) \frac xy

does not exist. Suppose x > 0. If y approaches 0 from above, then y > 0 and x/y > 0 and


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to0^+) \frac xy = +\infty

which you can convince yourself is true by reversing the example from before. Let x = 1 and take y from the sequence of decreasing powers of 10, {1/10, 1/10², 1/10³, …}, which converges to 0. Then

1/(1/10) = 10

1/(1/10²) = 100

1/(1/10³) = 1000

and so on. The smaller y gets (while still being positive), the larger x/y becomes.

But now suppose y < 0 and that y approaches 0 from below. Then x/y < 0, and


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to0^-) \frac xy = -\infty

The limits from either side do not match, so the limit as y approaches 0 does not exist.

You can use the same reasoning for when x < 0.

The case of x = 0 is special, however. Since y is approaching 0, it's never actually the case that y = 0. 1/y is then some non-zero real number, and multiplying it by x = 0 makes x/y = 0. Then


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to0) \frac 0y = 0

So in general,


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to0) \frac xy = \begin{cases}0 &amp; \text{if }x = 0 \\ \text{does not exist} &amp; \text{otherwise}\end{cases}

User Dejan Skledar
by
8.6k points

No related questions found

Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.

9.4m questions

12.2m answers

Categories