Your answer would be the second option, (-4,5).
We can find this by substituting in each point into the equation y < |x - 3| and seeing if it is true.
For the first one you get 1 < |2 - 1|. |2 - 1| = |-1| = 1, and 1 cannot be less than itself, so this is false.
For the second one you get 5 < |-4 - 3|. |-4 - 3| = |-7| = 7, and 5 is indeed less than 7, so this is correct.
I hope this helps!