111k views
5 votes
Pretend a person can walk only at a certain pace – no faster, no slower. If you time her uninterrupted walk across a room of known length, you can calculate her walking speed. If, however, she stops momentarily along the way to greet others in the room, the extra time spent in her brief interactions gives an average speed across the room that is less than her walking speed. How is this like light passing through glass? In what way is it not?

User Bacara
by
2.8k points

2 Answers

5 votes

Final answer:

The analogy between a person walking and stopping in a room and light traveling through glass highlights how interactions can lead to reduced average speeds. Light's apparent slowdown in glass is due to absorption and re-emission, contrasting with actual stops made by the walker. Time perception can also differ between observers based on relative motion, as illustrated by relativity.

Step-by-step explanation:

The example of a person walking across a room and stopping to greet others is analogous to light passing through glass. Light moves at a constant velocity in a vacuum, but when it enters a medium like glass, it interacts with the atoms and molecules within the material, which slows down the light's average speed in a way similar to the walker's reduced average speed due to pauses. However, unlike the person who stops and interacts, light does not actually pause; it is absorbed and re-emitted by atoms, a process that takes time and gives the appearance of slowing down.

As far as the dissimilarities are concerned, the pedestrian's reduction in average speed is due to actual stops, while light's reduction in average velocity does not involve any cessation of motion; the light is continuously in the process of absorption and re-emission by atoms.

Relativity provides another context where elapsed time can be different depending on the observer. For instance, an astronaut moving at near-light speeds experiences time differently compared to an observer on Earth. However, within the astronaut's frame of reference, all clocks indicate the same passage of time due to zero relative velocity. Motion and the passage of time are relative, not absolute.

User David Gomes
by
3.1k points
6 votes

Step-by-step explanation:

If a person is set to walk on a constant speed regardless of the situations then if the person walks a certain distance with no interruptions in an observed time then her speed can be calculated.

When the same person walking through the room momentarily stops to introduce herself then the average speed of the of the person slows down as it happens with the light wave when passes through glass which is an optically denser medium than the air, but the light wave does not stop anywhere in the medium.

It can be more relevant to the person's speed when she walks wading through the water or the person walks through the sand then the person feels resistance in the sand or in water which reduces her overall speed.

User Mikl X
by
3.5k points