305,600 views
9 votes
9 votes
Does the government get its power from the people, or do people get their power from the government? Explain the reasoning behind your belief and use examples to support it.

User Rafaecheve
by
2.9k points

1 Answer

22 votes
22 votes

Final answer:

Governments derive their power from the people through the concept of popular sovereignty, emphasizing that people establish and give authority to governments. This principle is deeply embedded in democratic societies and is evident in the governance structure of the United States, where the legitimacy of leaders comes from the will of the electorate. Sovereignty lies with the people who choose their representatives and can remove them if they fail to fulfill their duties.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question of whether the government gets its power from the people, or the people get their power from the government, is rooted in the concept of popular sovereignty. Historically and philosophically, it is recognized that people establish governments and are the source of all governmental powers. Popular sovereignty means that a government's legitimacy comes from the consent of the governed, a principle that is at the heart of democratic systems such as the United States. The authority that national leaders have is granted to them through the Constitution, reflecting the will of the people who elect representatives to exercise power on their behalf. This system ensures that when officials are voted out of office, it is a sign that the people's trust has shifted or that they believe another person can do a better job. Thus, the sovereignty lies with the people, who choose who will govern them.

By the people, for the people, and of the people is a core belief that drives American democracy, as evidenced by Abraham Lincoln's famous Gettysburg Address. This notion signifies that a government must serve the populous and that the people have the supreme power. In the American historical context, having emerged from the control of a monarchy, establishing a government controlled by the people was critical to the foundation of the nation.

Overall, governments evolved when people realized that collective security was more effective and that some individuals should have more authority to lead. This eventually transformed into the organized structures we see in modern governments. Today's democratic governments maintain the essence of sovereignty through free elections and constitutional governance, ensuring the government's power is grounded in the choice and consent of its people.

User Bizmate
by
3.1k points