Question

DEBATE THE FEDERAL BUDGET------50 PIONTS!!!!!

Topic:
The U.S. House of Representatives is debating discretionary spending for a new
Congressional budget. Some representatives want to allocate more funds for defense
spending. Others want to create a federal grant to states for a social service program
that would benefit families in low-income communities.

Assignment:
Imagine you are a Congressional aide. Help your representative prepare
for a debate on the budget by completing the notes below. Choose one side of the
issue: provide more money for defense or funds for a federal grant. Complete research
on this topic, using a variety of online sources. Then fill out the worksheet.

Claim: ______________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
Supporting Reason: __________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
Supporting Evidence: _________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
Supporting Evidence: _________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
Counterclaim: _______________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
Rebuttal: ____________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________

Answer 1

Answer: Claim: Allocating more funds for defence spending is crucial for national security and maintaining a strong military presence.

Supporting Reason: A well-funded defence sector is essential to protect the country from external threats and maintain peace.

Supporting Evidence: According to the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023, increasing defence spending would help strengthen national security by providing necessary resources for modernizing military equipment and technology.

The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget states that base defence spending is capped at $886 billion for FY 2024, which represents a 3% increase from FY 2023.

Counterclaim: Critics argue that allocating more funds for defence spending could lead to an imbalance in resource allocation and neglect other important areas such as social services.

Rebuttal: While it’s important to invest in social services, a strong defense is the foundation of a secure nation. By prioritizing defence spending, we can ensure the safety of our citizens and maintain stability in an increasingly complex global landscape.