The student made the mistake in step 2 while calculating the values of x ( option A)
The root of a quadratic equation can be found by using factorization method,
x² + 14x + 45 = 0
x² + 5x + 9x + 45 = 0
(x² + 5x )(+9x + 45) = 0
x(x +5) 9 ( x +5) = 0
(x + 9) ( x +5) = 0
step 2 should be ;
x+9 = 0
or x +5 = 0
But the student wrote x - 9 = 0 or x + 5 = 0
step 3 is x = -9 or -5
Therefore he made the mistake in step 2 by writing x - 9 instead of x +9