126k views
3 votes
All of the following are statements that are true EXCEPT:

A) Counselors should consult with colleagues when they are uncertain about exceptions to confidentiality
B) Confidentiality and privilege belong to the client, not the counselor
C) Confidentiality and privilege are absolute
D) Counselors should consult with colleagues when they are uncertain about an exception to privilege communication
E) Both confidentiality and privilege communication are based on a client's right to privacy

User BaldDude
by
9.5k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The statement 'Confidentiality and privilege are absolute' is not true as there are legally and ethically permissible exceptions to confidentiality and privilege. These concepts are fundamental to the client's right to privacy, but not without limits. This encompasses various domains such as counseling and journalism, where the confidentiality of the client or source is paramount yet can be contested under certain legal conditions. The correct answer is C.

Step-by-step explanation:

In the context of a counseling or legal setting, all statements provided are true EXCEPT 'C) Confidentiality and privilege are absolute'. This statement is incorrect because there are certain circumstances where confidentiality and privilege can be broken, such as when there is an imminent risk of harm to the client or others, or as mandated by law (e.g., reporting child abuse).

Indeed, counselors should consult with colleagues when uncertain about exceptions to confidentiality (A) and privilege communication (D), as collaboration can help clarify ethical and legal responsibilities. Confidentiality and privilege do indeed belong to the client (B) and are rooted in the client's right to privacy (E).

Certain rights such as the right to remain silent and the right to legal counsel are established to protect the privacy and dignity of individuals, particularly in legal settings—the right to not incriminate oneself and to seek legal representation. While confidentiality and privacy are critical to build trust, they are not without their limits or challenges.

Anonymity provided by reporters to their sources, also known as reporter's privilege, serves as an example of confidentiality in journalism, and although it is a practice protected by the First Amendment, it can come into conflict with legal proceedings, as seen in historical cases like that of Judith Miller.

User Arvin Jayanake
by
8.2k points