82.3k views
5 votes
Debunked myth of "cultural evolution" and subsistence patterns

1 Answer

3 votes

Final Answer:

The myth of "cultural evolution" posited that societies progress linearly from primitive to advanced based on their subsistence patterns. However, this concept has been debunked as it oversimplifies the complexity of cultural development and fails to account for diverse social, environmental, and historical factors influencing societies.

Step-by-step explanation:

The notion of "cultural evolution" implied a unidirectional trajectory from simpler to more complex societies solely based on subsistence patterns, like hunter-gatherer to agrarian to industrial societies. However, this oversimplification disregards the intricate interplay of various elements shaping cultures. Societies don't uniformly progress along a linear path due to multifaceted influences such as environmental changes, technological advancements, and social dynamics. For instance, some societies might maintain hunter-gatherer practices not due to lack of progress but because those patterns are adapted to their environment or cultural preferences.

Subsistence patterns aren't deterministic indicators of a society's advancement. The myth assumes an inherent hierarchy of societal development, but in reality, cultures exhibit diverse trajectories influenced by unique historical, geographical, and social circumstances. The myth fails to consider the resilience and adaptability of various subsistence practices that might persist due to cultural significance, environmental suitability, or socioeconomic factors. Moreover, it overlooks instances where societies might innovate and advance within their existing subsistence patterns rather than conforming to a predefined evolutionary model.

In debunking this myth, it's crucial to recognize the nuanced nature of cultural evolution. Societies aren't static entities following a predetermined path; instead, they adapt, innovate, and evolve in multifaceted ways that cannot be solely defined by their subsistence patterns. Understanding cultural development requires a holistic approach, considering the intricate web of historical legacies, environmental dynamics, technological innovations, and socio-cultural factors that shape the tapestry of human societies.

COMPLETE QUESTION:

Wjhat is debunked myth of "cultural evolution" and subsistence patterns?

User Josh Wright
by
9.3k points