Disk method it is, since both given options integrate with respect to y.
First find where the boundaries of the region intersect.
• y = x ³ and y = 1 intersect at (1, 1)
• y = x ³ and x = 3 intersect at (3, 27)
• y = 1 and x = 3 intersect at (1, 3)
So the bounded region is the set of points
(x, y)
But since we're integrating with respect to y, rewrite this set so that y has constant limits:
∛y ≤ x ≤ 3 and 1 ≤ y ≤ 27
Pick some point y in the interval [1, 27] and construct a disk centered at the given axis of revolution (x = 3). Such a disk will have radius 3 - ∛y because x = ∛y is the horizontal distance from the y-axis to the curve y = x ³ and x = 3 is itself 3 units away from the y-axis. Its height will be some small change in y, call it ∆y. Then the volume of this disk is
π (3 - ∛y )² ∆y
Now do the same thing for every y in [1, 27] - infinitely many of them! - and make ∆y very small, such that ∆y → dy. The volume of the solid is the sum total of the volumes of these infinitely many disks, given by the integral
and so the answer is A (assuming the limits of integration are listed from upper to lower).