47.0k views
4 votes
"Had Goodman Brown... only dreamed a wild dream of a witch-meeting?"

(paragraph 71). How are we to answer this question? Point out other places
where Hawthorne leaves the interpretation of the story ambiguous. How is
such ambiguity related to the story's theme?

User Selfish
by
7.6k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Nathaniel Hawthorne's deliberate ambiguity in "Young Goodman Brown" persists throughout the narrative, compelling readers to ponder the story's reality.

How to explain

Beyond Brown's dream-like encounter, Hawthorne interlaces uncertainty in various instances. For instance, the credibility of the devil's appearance, the forest's supernatural aura, and the sudden vanishing of the sinister figures all blur reality.

Such ambiguity intensifies the theme of moral uncertainty and the fragility of faith. It challenges the boundary between truth and illusion, leaving readers to grapple with the unsettling notion that reality may be distorted, much like Brown's wavering belief in the goodness of humanity amidst the enigmatic and morally ambiguous events.

User Abeauchamp
by
8.9k points