Question

Read the following reflective essay, then critique it. Use the following rubric as a basis for what to include in your critique.

My Little Brother
In my short life, there are many experiences that could qualify as life-changing. Every new experience was, at one time or another, the first experience. For good or bad, each instance
changed the course that my life has taken. But, the most transformative experience was the birth
of my youngest brother.
Joel is someone my parents often call a happy accident. At the time that my mother became
pregnant, I was 13, and my other brother, Jake, was 10. We were what you would call a well-
rounded, perfect family of four. We neatly fit into the perfect classification in nearly every way.
We didn't realize what we were missing until the moment that my youngest brother first opened
his striking blue eyes.
In truth, I resented the fact that I would be having another sibling. Nothing needed to be added
to our family, and my mother, already 38 at the time, was considered high risk because of her
age. The pregnancy itself was full of complications that sent the straight course of my life into
rollercoaster-like loops that my 13-year-old mind had a hard time comprehending. But now, I can
see how forging through those loops helped me to roll with the punches that life inevitably brings​

Answer 1

The 'My Little Brother' essay effectively uses personal testimony to convey transformation but could delve deeper into emotional nuances. Reflective elements are present but further analysis and evaluation of personal growth would enhance the essay. Tightening the introduction, providing clearer insights, and strengthening the conclusion would further improve the piece.

Step-by-step explanation:

Critiquing the reflective essay titled 'My Little Brother', it is apparent that the writer successfully employs personal testimony and informed opinion to express how the birth of a sibling can be transformative. The narrative begins with a broad statement about life experiences and quickly focuses on a significant event: the birth of a younger brother. Indicators of reflection and personal growth are evident as the writer moves from resentment to an appreciation of the new family dynamic.

Areas of exploration within the reflective writing are properly handled. The essay provides context for the 'happening', explains the initial approach and feelings towards the event, and eventually showcases a transformed perspective. It is critical, however, to consider how well the piece engages with reflective elements such as describing, analyzing, and evaluating the personal growth experienced by the writer.

In terms of improvement, the essay could benefit from a deeper exploration of the rollercoaster emotions and the specific ways in which dealing with these challenges has shaped the writer's character or worldview. Perhaps the introduction could be tighter, and certain passages could provide clearer insights into the writer's developmental journey. The conclusion could also be enhanced by summarizing reflective insights more succinctly.