161k views
4 votes
Ex: Ms. Smith has written several books arguing that women are discriminated against in the workplace. But she is just ugly and bitter, so why should we listen to her?

1 Answer

1 vote

Final answer:

Personal appearance and feelings should not discredit an author's argument. Assess arguments based on evidence, reasoning, and credibility. Do not resort to personal attacks or judgment based on appearances.

Step-by-step explanation:

Ms. Smith's physical appearance and personal feelings should not discredit the argument she presents in her books. When analyzing any argument, it is important to focus on the evidence, reasoning, and credibility of the author rather than making judgments based on their appearance or personal experiences. Looking at the credibility of Ms. Smith, her books may contain research, case studies, statistical data, and expert opinions that provide evidence for her argument about workplace discrimination against women.


An individual's physical appearance or personal feelings do not negate the validity of their arguments. It is important to assess arguments based on their logical reasoning, supporting evidence, and the credibility of the author. Moreover, dismissing someone's perspective based on their appearance is an ad hominem fallacy, which is a logical error in reasoning.


In conclusion, we should evaluate arguments and perspectives on their own merit, rather than resorting to personal attacks or judgment based on appearances. By focusing on the evidence and reasoning presented by the author, we can have a more meaningful and informed discussion about the topic at hand.

User JobJob
by
7.5k points