157k views
5 votes
Does the focus on "humane" killing of animals distract from the real moral problem of killing?

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

The focus on 'humane' killing of animals can distract from the real moral problem of killing. It diverts attention from the larger moral question of whether it is morally justified to kill animals at all. It is important to address the fundamental moral issue of killing itself.

Step-by-step explanation:

The focus on 'humane' killing of animals can indeed distract from the real moral problem of killing. While the concept of 'humane' killing suggests that there is an ethical way to take an animal's life, it still brings up ethical questions regarding the value and rights of animals. By focusing on the manner in which killing is carried out, it can divert attention from the larger moral question of whether it is morally justified to kill animals at all. The argument for focusing on 'humane' killing is often rooted in the belief that if animals must be killed, it should be done in a way that minimizes suffering. However, this argument assumes that we have the right to decide the fate of animals and determine what constitutes a 'humane' death for them. This raises questions about the inherent value of animal life and whether it can be justifiably taken for human benefit. Instead of getting sidetracked by the nuances of 'humane' killing, it is important to address the fundamental moral issue of killing itself. This involves exploring the reasons for killing animals, evaluating our ethical responsibilities towards them, and considering alternative ways of interacting with and utilizing animals that do not involve taking their lives.

User Meiyun
by
7.9k points