Question

In the poem, "David Matherne Pipe Organs—dusty and tarnished—bellowed the ancient song," various scenes unfold, portraying a vivid narrative. Sally Richards witnesses her father's departure amid the melancholy atmosphere, while stained-glass windows survey the commotion, acknowledging commerce's triumph. The Reverend Richards, feeble and finished, reflects on a changing era as Christians worship the dime.

Question:
Which words best describe the speaker’s tone toward the subject matter of the poem?

Responses:
a) Sad, but upbeat
b) Sarcastically honest
c) Courageously critical
d) Heartbreaking, but realistic

Answer 1

The speaker's tone in the poem is best described as d) 'heartbreaking, but realistic,' due to the use of melancholic imagery and a critical observation of change.

Step-by-step explanation:

The speaker's tone in the poem can be best described as d) heartbreaking, but realistic (option d).

The imagery used throughout the provided text excerpts, such as the dusty and tarnished pipe organs, stained-glass windows surveying, and Christians worshipping the dime, suggests a melancholic ambience and a critical observation of change.

Moreover, the somber Gothic pile, the description of Roderick Usher's lost vigor, and the negative transformation of Goodman Brown reinforce a tone of realism blended with sorrow, aligning with option d).