Question

3. Using only story details from this excerpt from Divergent, argue for or against the claim:

Tris is a hero and not an anti-hero. Must be a CER and use information from the
definitions and the story.

Answer 1

Tris in 'Divergent' may be argued to be a hero based on traditional virtues that she exhibits, such as bravery and selflessness. The assertion that Tris is a hero rather than an anti-hero should be supported by strong evidence from the text, analyzing her behaviors and decisions.

Step-by-step explanation:

In Divergent, the character Tris can be argued to fit the role of a hero rather than an anti-hero, based on the information provided. A hero traditionally exhibits virtues such as courage, selflessness, and determination, often engaging in actions that result in the greater good. The definition of an anti-hero, in contrast, includes protagonists who lack conventional heroic qualities but are still the central characters. Based on story details, if Tris demonstrates bravery, self-sacrifice, and moral integrity in her endeavors within the narrative, she aligns more closely with the archetype of a traditional hero. To support the assertion that Tris is a hero, one would need to provide evidence of her engaging in actions that are altruistic and for the benefit of others, overcoming personal obstacles, and maintaining moral principles even when faced with adversity. These characteristics are indicative of a hero's journey in literature.

It is also essential to avoid the obvious conclusions and instead provide strong evidence from the text to substantiate the classification of Tris as a hero rather than an anti-hero. This entails a close analysis of Tris's behavior, decisions, and the impact of her actions on those around her within the context of the story. Ultimately, whether or not Tris is considered a hero will depend upon the text's portrayal of her character through these elements.

Answer 2

Throughout the story, Tris consistently demonstrates qualities associated with traditional heroes.

She displays bravery, selflessness, and a willingness to sacrifice for the greater good. For instance, her decision to choose Dauntless over her family's faction shows her courage and determination to overcome challenges.

Tris's motivations align with the typical hero archetype. She is driven by a desire to protect others and create a better society. Her actions are not fueled by selfishness or personal gain but rather by a sense of responsibility and moral duty. This is evident in her participation in the initiation process, where she strives to prove herself for the benefit of the community.