The most likely evidence from 2005 that suggests possible contamination is that the sediments exhibit an orange color and water in the pond has an unusual green color.
Orange color could indicate the presence of iron oxide (rust) which is often associated with acid mine drainage (AMD). AMD occurs when water reacts with minerals in exposed rock, like those found in coal mines, and becomes acidic. Iron-bearing minerals in the rock dissolve in the acidic water, resulting in the orange color.
Unusual green color could be a sign of excessive algal growth. Algae thrive in nutrient-rich environments, and AMD can introduce various nutrients like phosphorus and nitrogen into the water. This can lead to eutrophication, where excessive algae bloom depletes oxygen levels in the water, harming other aquatic life.