Question

Which moral dilemma do the characters in “Subha” face?

B) The parents must either deceive a man into marrying their daughter or keep her with them forever.

C:)Pratap must decide if he will go against caste and marry Subha or watch her leave to marry a stranger.

D)Subha’s sisters must decide whether or not to tell the handsome stranger that their sister cannot speak

Answer 1

In the story 'Subha' by Rabindranath Tagore, the characters face the moral dilemma of deciding whether to deceive a man into marrying their mute daughter or keep her at home, reflecting a conflict between societal expectations and ethical integrity.

Step-by-step explanation:

The moral dilemma in the short story Subha by Rabindranath Tagore revolves around the challenges that the character Subha, a mute girl, and her family face in a traditional society. The specific dilemma mentioned in the question is option B, where the parents of Subha must decide whether to deceive a man into marrying their mute daughter or to keep her with them indefinitely, essentially withholding her chance to lead a normal married life. This situation reflects a deep moral conflict as the parents grapple with the societal pressures of marrying off a daughter and the ethical implications of deceiving someone into a lifetime commitment.

This moral quandary can be likened to philosophical discussions such as those found in Plato's Euthyphro, which debates the nature of piety and ethics. Faced with the decision to protect a family member or uphold the truth, an individual wrestles with conflicting duties and the pursuit of what is considered 'the right thing to do.' Similarly, in Tagore's story, the characters must weigh the nuances of familial obligation against moral honesty.

Answer 2

The best answer for this question would be:

C) Pratap must decide if he will go against caste and marry Subha or watch her leave to marry a stranger.

The story tests the choices that we make, and the conflicts that we will eventually encounter with that decision.