5.0k views
0 votes
America's first elections involved public voting by voice. With the many problems plaguing existing voting systems, is it possible that voice voting might make a comeback? Why or why not?

User Yamileth
by
6.6k points

2 Answers

4 votes

Final answer:

The return of voice voting in the U.S. is unlikely due to privacy and efficiency concerns as well as the potential for coercion. Current systems, from mechanical to electronic, aim to safeguard vote integrity and privacy, while challenges in the "first past the post" system and the Electoral College spur debates on reform rather than looking to older methods.

Step-by-step explanation:

The prospect of voice voting making a comeback in America's current electoral system is highly unlikely due to various concerns related to privacy, efficiency, and the potential for intimidation or coercion. With the evolution of voting systems, the United States has transitioned to methods that aim to enhance the integrity and confidentiality of the voting process. These methods range from mechanical voting machines to electronic touch screen systems, which offer a more secure and verifiable way of casting votes compared to public voice voting.

Moreover, America's "first past the post" voting system, where the candidate with the most votes wins, is already under scrutiny for problems such as the potential to distort majority preference, misrepresentation of voters' intentions, and low voter turnout. The intricacies and challenges of the current electoral system — including the controversy surrounding the Electoral College — further complicate the idea of reverting to voice voting. Instead, discussions and efforts are more focused on reforms to improve existing systems, like advocating for direct popular votes, addressing issues of voter access and rights, and exploring alternative voting systems that could better represent the will of the electorate.

User Dru
by
6.3k points
3 votes
no, voice voting is no coming back,

The voice voting method is only possible in simple societies whose demography is not extensive. It is prone to several challenges and malpractices than other forms of voting because there are no reference point once people have responded orally.
User Meyertee
by
6.0k points