Question

Why did Odysseus keep his identity a secret to the Phaeacians?

Answer 1

Odysseus kept his identity secret from the Phaeacians to protect himself and assess their intentions, a strategy shaped by his previous experiences and the need for caution due to his fame.

Step-by-step explanation:

Odysseus kept his identity a secret from the Phaeacians for a variety of reasons related to his shrewd and cautious nature. He was aware that revealing his identity could potentially lead to danger or complications, especially if the information was misused or if treacherous plans were made against him as a result of his fame. Being a hero from the Trojan War, Odysseus's reputation preceded him, and there were many who bore grudges or might seek revenge. By withholding his identity, Odysseus protected himself and assessed the situation, ensuring the Phaeacians' intentions were hospitable before trusting them with his true identity. Moreover, his experiences with deception and disguise, such as his encounter with the Cyclops Polyphemus, taught him the value of strategy over brute force. Therefore, discretion was a key part of his survival strategy following his epic journey filled with mythical and real threats.

Answer 2

One reason Odysseus does not reveal his identity when he is in the land of Phaeacia is because the people of this country are good hosts. Part of proper hospitality in the Odyssey involves not asking a guest his or her name until the guest has been fed and offered other hospitality.