For this case we can translate the sentence given as:
The baseball player catches (catches) _______ with __________.
We know that the baseball game basically consists of batting balls effectively to score in the race, the opponent will try to catch the balls with the glove to prevent the batter from moving from the base.
Then, the baseball player catches balls and catches them with the glove.
Thus, the sentence is completed as:
The baseball player catches the ball with the glove
La jugadora de béisbol atrapa la pelota con el guante
Answer:
Option D