94.3k views
0 votes
80 POINTS! Refer to the Newsela article "PRO/CON: Should We Abolish the Electoral College?"

Part A

Read the text under the heading "PRO: Let's Give All Voters an Equal Voice."

Which claim does the author make as a pro for doing away with the Electoral College.


The popular vote determines the winner in a presidential election.

The Senate and the House of Representatives have an equal voice in shaping government.

The way the federal government is set up ensures that the minority has a voice.

It is important to ensure that small states have an equal voice.
Question 2
Part B

Read this excerpt from the article.

The U.S. Senate gives states equal representation with two senators each. The House of Representatives, however, allocates representation based on population.

Does this excerpt provide evidence that effectively supports the claim identified in Part A?


Yes, because it provides an example of the way in which the federal government gives smaller states a voice.

No, because it does not provide an explanation for how the federal government is set up.

Yes, because it gives evidence that the Constitution provides a voice for minorities.

No, because it describes the legislature alone and not other parts of government.

User Gnanagurus
by
4.6k points

2 Answers

0 votes

Final answer:

The author's pro claim for abolishing the Electoral College is that the popular vote should determine election outcomes. The legislative excerpt doesn't effectively support this claim as it doesn't relate directly to the Electoral College. The Electoral College protects smaller states' interests, which could be important for balanced representation.

Step-by-step explanation:

The claim made by the author under the heading "PRO: Let's Give All Voters an Equal Voice" as a pro for doing away with the Electoral College is that the popular vote should determine the winner in a presidential election, ensuring that all voters have an equal voice.

Regarding Part B, the excerpt from the article mentioning the Senate and the House of Representatives does not provide evidence that effectively supports the claim identified in Part A. This is because it describes the legislature alone and does not address the entirety of how the federal government is set up, which is necessary to establish a link with how the Electoral College affects the presidential election process.

The current Electoral College system protects the representative power of small states and less densely populated regions by assigning a minimum number of electors regardless of population. This could be regarded as important to preserve because without the Electoral College, these regions might be ignored by presidential candidates who would likely focus on more populous areas, potentially leading to a dominance of policy preferences by larger states at the expense of less populous ones.

User Mbonness
by
5.4k points
6 votes

Answer:

A

Step-by-step explanation:

i think its A........

User Pavel Nikolov
by
4.7k points