52.8k views
5 votes
Reread paragraph 1. How does the structure of the paragraph show the illogical reaction to Moses?

Re-read paragraph 12. identify the sentence fragments. What effect do these fragments have on the reader?

Re-read paragraph 12. how does the author compare Tubman's possible fate to that of the runaways?

Re-read paragraph 17. what effect does the use of the repeoted phrose, "would have to..." have on the
reader?


The passage..
“Harriet Tubman: Conductor on the Underground Railroad” by Ann Petry

Paragraph 1 -
“Along the Eastern Shore of Maryland, in Dorchester County, in Caroline County, the masters kept hearing whispers about the man named Moses, who was running off slaves. At first they did not believe in his existence. The stories about him was so fantastic, unbelievable. Yet they watched for him. They offered rewards for his capture.”

Paragraph 12-
“But there were so many of them this time. She knew moments of doubt when she was half afraid, and kept looking back over her shoulder, imagining that she heard the sound of pursuit. They would certainly be pursued. Eleven of them. Eleven thousand dollars’ worth of flesh and bone and muscle that belong to the Maryland planters. If they were caught, the eleven runaways would be whipped and sold South, but she— she will be probably be hanged.”

Paragraph 17-
“ she turned away from the house, frowning. She had promised her passengers food and rest and warmth, and instead of that, there would be hunger and cold and more walking over the frozen ground. Somehow she would have to instill courage into these eleven people, most of them strangers, would have to feed them on hope and bright dreams of freedom instead of the fried pork and corn bread and milk she had promised them.”

2 Answers

6 votes

Final answer:

The first paragraph shows the illogical response to Moses by emphasizing disbelief coupled with vigilant actions of the slave masters. Sentence fragments in paragraph 12 evoke Tubman's anxiety and urgency. The repeated phrase 'would have to' in paragraph 17 underscores Tubman's determination and sense of responsibility.

Step-by-step explanation:

  1. In 'Harriet Tubman: Conductor on the Underground Railroad' by Ann Petry, the first paragraph utilizes incredulity in the structure to depict the illogical reactions to the mythical figure of Moses, who is actually Harriet Tubman. The disbelief of the slave masters is emphasized through their own contradictions; they find the tales of Moses 'unbelievable' yet simultaneously 'watched for him' and offered rewards, showing a conflicted mentality.
  2. In paragraph 12, the sentence fragments "She knew moments of doubt. And kept looking back over her shoulder." convey a sense of frantic, interrupted thought, mirroring Tubman's anxiety about being pursued. These fragments make the reader feel the urgency and fear that Tubman experiences.
  3. Furthermore, the comparison of Tubman's fate to that of the runaways is stark; while they might be sold or whipped, Tubman likely faces death by hanging, highlighting the gravity of her risk versus that of others.
  4. The repeated phrase 'would have to' in paragraph 17 creates an overwhelming sense of responsibility and challenge that Tubman feels in leading her passengers to freedom. It reflects the relentless obstacles she faces and the determination required to overcome them, intensifying the reader's admiration for her courage and dedication.
User Joshua Grigonis
by
8.7k points
1 vote
I don’t knownsjddxhxjx
User Angely
by
8.2k points