I'm a huge Broadway guy, and the stuff i'm listening to rn is; all american prophet, suddenly semour, without love, la vie boheme, andy's song, cautionary tale, michael in the bathroom, cabinet battle #1, me and the sky, blankets and bedding, voices in my head, joseph megamix, laundry day, simple sponge, the other side, and rewrite the stars.
if you listen with an open mind, I think you'll like it. You don't really need to know the background of each song and where it is in the plot of the show. Broadway is actually good even though it gets a bad rep.