175k views
4 votes
HIN

The cliff dwellings in Mesa Verde
National Park are accessible to visitors
only when accompanied by a park
ranger. Billy is at a cliff dwelling in
Mesa Verde National Park. So, Billy
(is, may be, is not) with a park ranger.
Deductive reasoning

1 Answer

4 votes

Answer: Be careful !

Billy is with a park ranger. Should be correct BUT

It is not given that Billy is visiting the cliff dwelling.

Billy may be the Park Ranger.

So Billy may be with a park ranger.

Explanation:

User Dmitrii Lobanov
by
8.3k points