Question

Michael was the main suspect of a murder that took place on Halloween night. Three rookie police officers parked in front of Michael's house for two hours and proceeded to knock on the front door. No one answered. The officers proceeded to go to the back yard and go up on the porch to knock on the door. Michael finally opened and the police walked in without being invited. The walked to the living room and proceeded to ask questions. Not satisfied with Michael's initial responses, each officer took turns to ask the similar questions while the other

two stood in the way of the two exits in hopes of getting an incriminating response. The encounter lasted for over an hour. Michael finally admitted to the crime and was charged with murder. Michael argues that his Miranda rights were violated. Do you agree? Why or why not?

Answer 1

Michael's Miranda rights were violated. This is because a part of the Miranda rights is the right to remain silent. When Michael stayed silent, the police officers forced their way into his home without consent. (which also violates his rights as this can only be done under specific circumstances)