173k views
0 votes
Daniel says that when the irrational number 7√3 is multiplied by any rational number, the product is always an irrational number. What value for the rational number disproves Daniel's claim?

User Serial
by
8.7k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Answer: 0

============================================

Step-by-step explanation:

When we multiply 0 by any number, we get 0 as a result

x*0 = 0

0*x = 0

for any number x.

The number 0 is rational since we can write it as a fraction of two integers

0 = 0/1

If Daniel were to correct his statement to say "multiply by any nonzero rational number", then his statement would be correct that the result is irrational.

----------------------------------------------

Extra info:

Here's a proof showing why Daniel's claim is correct if we consider nonzero rational numbers

Let p be a nonzero rational number, so p = a/b for integers a,b where neither a or b are zero

Let q be an irrational number. We cannot write q as a ratio of two integers

The claim is that p*q is irrational. For now let's assume the opposite. So assume p*q is rational. This means p*q = r/s for integers r,s

This would be the same as (a/b)*q = r/s which solves to q = (r/s)*(b/a) = (rb)/(sa) making q rational, but that contradicts the fact we made q irrational earlier.

Therefore, the assumption p*q is rational cannot be the case, and p*q must be irrational.

User Yogesh Maheshwari
by
9.0k points

Related questions

Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.

9.4m questions

12.2m answers

Categories