$1500 will be paid by the Insurance policy as the accident has lead to $725 damage to John’a car which will be covered up to $500 (full amount that insurance can pay), leaving him to pay off the rest. As for the liability that is worth $1525 so insurance will pay what it can which is $1000, leaving John to pay off the remaining amount. So the insurance is paying $1500 ($500 comprehensive coverage plus $1000 liability coverage)