Answer:
35.35%
Explanation:
If there were no deductibles, the expected claim payment would be:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ab1d2/ab1d288784b552295cbe0efa2e8efd8243c03b6f" alt="E(X) = (10,000 +1,000)/(2) \\E(X) =\$5,500"
If the collision insurance claim is under $2,000, then the insurer would not pay anything, but if X > $2,000, then the insurer would pay X - $2,000. The new expected value is:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5dbac/5dbac47e8358db813da55aae46faf30f2077c00a" alt="E_2(X)=(2,000-1,000)/(10,000-1,000) *0+(10,000-2,000)/(10,000-1,000)*((2,000-2,000)+(10,000-2,000))/(2) \\E_2(X)=(8)/(9)*(0+8,000)/(2)\\ E_2(X)=\$3,555.56"
The percentage reduction on the claim payment is:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e99bb/e99bb8af5a6f6bbe228ef1501602e3781b676036" alt="P=(1-(E_2(X))/(E(X)))*100 \\P=(1-(3,555.56)/(5,500))*100\\P=35.35\%"
There was a 35.35% reduction.