Answer
A. Everything the fortune cookie predicted would happen to Kyle came true.
Explanation
C and D. There is no supernatural element to the story
For C they compete to create a haunted house but there’s no paranormal activity (I.e ghosts) which would suggest there’s anything supernatural.
For B the traffic lights could have been green due to probability/chance. It also doesn’t state how many intersections there were.
For A, there is some mysterious/supernatural element in the fact that a cookie was able to provide Kyle’s destiny/future.