62.4k views
4 votes
Question 22 1 point possible (graded) In which of the following ways do utilitarians and Aristotle stand united against Rawls’s liberalism? a) Utilitarians and Aristotle believe in natural rights, whereas Rawlsian liberals are concerned mostly with liberty. b) Utilitarians and Aristotle both believe that the government should attempt to maximize the aggregate of pleasure minus pain, whereas Rawlsian believe that the government should simply protect rights. c) Utilitarians and Aristotle start by asking what things are good and then argue that the government should advance the good, whereas Rawlsian liberals believe that the government should not advance any particular conception of the good. d) a and c e) b and c

2 Answers

5 votes

Final answer:

Utilitarians and Aristotle argue for advancing what they see as 'the good' in society, while Rawlsian liberalism focuses on establishing just principles without endorsing a particular conception of the good.

Step-by-step explanation:

Utilitarianism, as conceived by Jeremy Bentham, focuses on outcomes and seeks to maximize pleasure and minimize pain for the greatest number. In contrast, Aristotle's virtue ethics emphasize achieving the good life by cultivating virtues in individuals. John Rawls's liberalism, particularly through his theory of justice, aims to design principles that rational individuals behind a veil of ignorance would choose to ensure fairness and equity in society.

Rawls is concerned with achieving a just society based on principles that ensure liberties and address inequality. His liberty principle suggests that each person should have an equal right to basic liberties, while his difference principle intends to benefit the least advantaged members of society by allowing inequalities only if they are attached to positions open under fair equality of opportunity.

The correct answer to the question is c) Utilitarians and Aristotle start by asking what things are good and then argue that the government should advance the good, whereas Rawlsian liberals believe that the government should not advance any particular conception of the good.

User GoldRoger
by
8.6k points
3 votes

Answer:

Correct Answer:

d) a and c

Step-by-step explanation:

Aristotle, Utilitarians and Rawlsian are various philosophers who hold various views on different aspect of life. One of the prominent is rights and liberty of an individual on this world. While Rawlsian believed that, everyone should enjoys the maximum liberty possible without intruding upon the freedom of others. On the other-hand, Aristotle and Utilitarians believed that, rights of an individual should be limited to that which naturally is obtainable to him or her.

User C Heyer
by
8.6k points