Your answer would be 37.5%
For the first card you picked, the probability of picking a number less than 3 is 2/4 = 1/2, because there are 2 cards that are less than 3 and a total of 4 cards.
When picking the second card, it is still out of 4 because you replaced the first one, so the probability of picking a card greater than 1 is 3/4 because there are 3 cards that are greater than 1 out of a total of 4.
Therefore the total probability would be 1/2 × 3/4 = 3/8. To find this as a percentage we just multiply by 100, and this gives us 37.5%.
I hope this helps!