111k views
24 votes
We see many things "clash" in the beginning chapters of Antigone. God's Rule and King's Rule, Kingdom and Family, Sisters, Brothers, Father and Son, and Young and Old. Pick one thing that "clashes" or is at odds with one another and analyze the two sides of the situation making sure to use one piece of evidence from the text for both side. Which side do you think is more correct and why?

User Joe Conway
by
3.9k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Answer:

Father and Son

Step-by-step explanation:

Both Creon and Haemon come to odds with each other regarding Antigone's death sentence. Haemon believes Creon should set Antigone free, because the people of Thebes "are upset about the girl" and "they say of all women here she least deserves the worst of deaths for her most glorious act". The citizens of Thebes support Antigone in her decision to go against Creon's decree and actually applaud her for it. On the other hand, Creon is blinded by the fact that anyone had dared to go against his word, especially a woman, and refuses to see the logic and reason in Haemon's argument. Creon states, "And men my age—are we then going to school to learn what's wise from men as young as him?". Creon attempts to downplay Haemon by pointing out the difference in their ages, beliving as the elder, Creon is wiser. Personally, I believe Haemon's side is more correct because it is supported with logical reason as opposed to just anger.

User Vitaut
by
3.8k points