16.8k views
0 votes
The retention time (tr) and peak width (w) for compounds A and B are given after chromatographic separation using five different experimental parameters. Which chromatographic separations achieved a resolution that is desirable for quantitative analysis?

a. Separation 1: compound A: t; = 13.0 min; w = 5.0 min compound B: t; = 17.0 min; w = 6.5 min
b. Separation 3: compound A: tr = 14.0 min; w = 4.0 min
c. Separation 2: compound A: t; = 10.0 min; w = 3.0 min compound B: t; = 19.0 min; w = 3.0 min
d. Separation 4: compound A: tr = 11.0 min; w = 2.0 min compound B: tr = 16.0 min; w = 5.0 min compound B: tr = 15.0 min; w = 3.0 min
e. Separation 5: compound A: tr = 9.0 min; w = 2.5 min compound B: t; = 13.0 min; w= 4.5 min

User ZhangChn
by
7.7k points

2 Answers

2 votes

Final answer:

To determine which chromatographic separations achieved a resolution that is desirable for quantitative analysis, we can calculate the resolution (R) for each separation. Separations 2 and 4 achieved resolutions that are desirable for quantitative analysis.

Step-by-step explanation:

To determine which chromatographic separations achieved a resolution that is desirable for quantitative analysis, we need to calculate the resolution for each separation.

Resolution (R) can be calculated using the formula:

R = 2 * (trB - trA) / (wA + wB)

where trA and trB are the retention times for compounds A and B, and wA and wB are the peak widths for compounds A and B, respectively.

Let's calculate the resolutions for each separation:

a. Separation 1: R = 2 * (17.0 min - 13.0 min) / (5.0 min + 6.5 min) = 0.57

b. Separation 3: R = Not possible to calculate the resolution as the peak width for compound B is not given.

c. Separation 2: R = 2 * (19.0 min - 10.0 min) / (3.0 min + 3.0 min) = 1.33

d. Separation 4: R = 2 * (16.0 min - 11.0 min) / (5.0 min + 2.0 min) = 1.78

e. Separation 5: R = 2 * (13.0 min - 9.0 min) / (2.5 min + 4.5 min) = 0.94

Based on the calculated resolutions, separations 2 and 4 achieved resolutions that are desirable for quantitative analysis as their R values are greater than 1.

User Rubia Gardini
by
8.1k points
4 votes

Answer:

Separation 2 has the highest resolution value which is 3, it is therefore the most desirable.

Step-by-step explanation:

Note that in the given separations, the values for compound B which are missing in separation 3 were erroneously put in separation 4. These are the correct values for separations:

a. Separation 1: compound A: t; = 13.0 min; w = 5.0 min compound B: t; = 17.0 min; w = 6.5 min

b. Separation 3: compound A: tr = 14.0 min; w = 4.0 min compound B: tr = 16.0 min; w = 5.0 min

c. Separation 2: compound A: t; = 10.0 min; w = 3.0 min compound B: t; = 19.0 min; w = 3.0 min

d. Separation 4: compound A: tr = 11.0 min; w = 2.0 min compound B: tr = 15.0 min; w = 3.0 min

e. Separation 5: compound A: tr = 9.0 min; w = 2.5 min compound B: t; = 13.0 min; w= 4.5 min

Determination of chromatographic separation that achieved a resolution that is desirable for quantitative analysis

In chromatography, the formula for Resolution (R) = 2(t­R(B)­ - t­R(A)­) / (W­B ­ + W ­A)

For separation 1 : Resolution (R) = 2(17.0 min - 13.0­ min) / (6.5min­ + 5.0min ) = 0.695

For separation 2 : Resolution (R) = 2(19.0 min - 10.0­ min) / (3.0min­ + 3.0min ) = 3

For separation 3 : Resolution (R) = 2(16.0 min - 14.0­ min) / (5.0min­ + 4.0min ) = 0.444

For separation 4 : Resolution (R) = 2(15.0 min - 11.0­ min) / (3.0min­ + 2.0min )

= 1.6

For separation 5 : Resolution (R) = 2(13.0 min - 9.0­ min) / (4.5min­ + 2.5min )

= 1.14

A chromatographic separation with a higher resolution is desirable for quantitative analysis. Since separation 2 has the highest resolution value which is 3, it is therefore the most desirable.

User Prateek Narendra
by
9.2k points
Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.