Answer:
Both students are right.
Explanation:
The product that the teacher wrote on the board is

One of his students called Miles, conclude that

is a factor of

This is very true because from the given product both 3x² and 4x are factors of 12x³.
Another student , Jude also concludes that 12x³ is divsible by 4x.
This is also true because:

Hence both students are correct.