35.4k views
3 votes
Read the excerpt below and answer the question.

These things look like the cautious patting and petting of a spirited horse preparatory to mounting him when it is dreaded that may give the rider a fall.




In at least 150 words, discuss how this analogy fits Lincoln's purpose in the "House Divided" speech. Identify what you think his purpose is, what the analogy is comparing, and how it fits with Lincoln's purpose. Add whatever historical context from the instruction you need.

User Gyurisc
by
4.4k points

1 Answer

3 votes

In the "House Divided" speech, Abraham Lincoln makes a prediction about the government of the United States. He tells us that he believes the country is unable to survive division. It cannot go on with half of the country accepting slavery and the other half outlawing it. Therefore, he predicts the country has to settle on one or the other.

Lincoln tells us that this debate is similar to the process that riders have before mounting a horse. He states that some riders pat and pet the horse because they are scared the horse might "give them a fall." However, he argues that this is a pointless and futile pursuit, much like that of defending slavery. The purpose of the analogy is to present, in simple terms, what the role of slavery should be in the Union, and how the effort to preserve it is bound to fail.

User AdamBT
by
4.1k points