Answer:
The total area of the two shapes is not equal, Chase is wrong
Explanation:
we know that
The surface area of a cylinder is given by the formula

where
r is the radius of the coin
h is the thickness of the coin
we have
Penny
The coin is 19.05 mm in diameter and 1.52 mm in thickness.
so


substitute in the formula



Quarter
The diameter is 24.26 mm and 1.75 mm in thickness.
so


substitute in the formula



therefore
The total area of the two shapes is not equal, Chase is wrong, because the coins have different diameter and thickness