Question

Compare the perspectives of the narrator and her first employers regarding wages. What does this comparison reveal about how they view immigrant labor? America and I

Answer 1

The contrast between the narrator's and employers' views on wages reflects the disparity between the idealized vision of America's economic opportunity and the grim reality of low-wage immigrant labor. While employers see it as a business advantage, immigrants often see it as a barrier to achieving the American Dream.

Step-by-step explanation:

When comparing the perspectives of the narrator and her first employers regarding wages, the employers likely view low wages as a reflection of the abundant supply of immigrant labor willing to accept lower pay, often driven by dire necessities. The narrator, as an immigrant, probably sees low wages as an unfair impediment to achieving the American Dream, juxtaposed with the struggle to survive day to day. This comparison highlights the contrasting views on the value of labor and the role of immigrants in the economy. Employers may perceive immigrant labor as a cheap commodity, while immigrants like the narrator view America as a place of economic opportunity that is being undercut by their low compensation.

The narratives presented show that American Exceptionalism and the belief in America as a unique land of opportunity can sometimes overshadow the economic inequalities and the challenges immigrants face. This comparison reveals a disparity between the idealized vision of America and the harsh realities of the labor market, compounded by the experiences of immigrants who often end up in low-wage jobs without a clear path to upward mobility.

Answer 2

Answers with Explanation:

1. Compare the perspectives of the narrator and her first employers regarding wages.

The narrator in the story views wage as an important aspect when applying for a job, especially when it comes to immigrant labor. The first employers, on the other hand, views asking a question about wages a sign of disrespect. They told Anzia that instead of thinking about wages, she should be thankful to be associated with the Americans.

2. What does this comparison reveal about how they view immigrant labor?

The narrator views immigrant labor as something that will free her from poverty and oppression. She thought that moving to another country, like America, would allow her the freedom to express herself and earn just amount of wage. However, for the employers, immigrant labor is something they take advantage of. They thought that they're superior than the immigrants, that's why they treat them with harsh labor and long hours of work.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question above is related to the essay entitled "America and I," written by Anzia Yazierska. It focuses on Anzia's struggles in adopting the lifestyle of American people.