231k views
5 votes
Fibroblasts are cells that can be isolated from the connective tissue under the skin and grown in culture. Normally these cells retain the properties of fibroblasts as they divide for many generations in culture, but if we do an experiment in which the fibroblasts are forced to take up a highly expressed copy of the MyoD gene, they rapidly differentiate to become muscle cells.

a) MyoD expression is sufficient to cause fibroblasts to differentiate to muscle cells in culture
b) MyoD expression is correlated with muscle cell differentiation in culture
c) MyoD expression is necessary and sufficient to cause fibroblasts to differentiate to muscle cells in culture
d) MyoD expression is necessary for fibroblasts to differentiate to muscle cells in culture

User Epoch
by
3.2k points

2 Answers

5 votes

Final answer:

MyoD expression, when introduced to fibroblasts in culture, is sufficient for their differentiation into muscle cells. This is supported by the experiment where fibroblasts transformed after being induced to express MyoD, but it's not definitively stated that MyoD is necessary, as other factors might also contribute to the differentiation process.

Step-by-step explanation:

Understanding MyoD in Cell Differentiation

Fibroblasts are a type of cell found in connective tissue and play a significant role in producing extracellular matrix components, like collagen and elastin. Muscle tissue, on the other hand, develops from myoblasts, which are embryonic cells that differentiate into muscle cells. This differentiation process is heavily influenced by various transcription factors, including MyoD, which is crucial for the formation of muscle cells. When fibroblasts in culture are forced to express the MyoD gene, they differentiate and take on the characteristics of muscle cells.

The statement 'MyoD expression is sufficient to cause fibroblasts to differentiate to muscle cells in culture' suggests that the presence and expression of MyoD alone can cause the fibroblasts to undergo differentiation into muscle cells. However, it is not clear whether MyoD is also necessary for this process, meaning that without it, differentiation would not occur.

The most accurate option, based on the experiment mentioned, is (a) 'MyoD expression is sufficient to cause fibroblasts to differentiate to muscle cells in culture'. Though MyoD is crucial, stating it is necessary and sufficient without ruling out the potential involvement of other factors could be presumptive. Therefore, without further evidence that MyoD is required (i.e., that in its absence fibroblasts cannot differentiate into muscle cells), we cannot confidently claim option (c) or (d).

User NewVigilante
by
3.6k points
4 votes

Answer:

The response is "MyoD expression is necessary and sufficient to cause fibroblasts to differentiate to muscle cells in culture"

Step-by-step explanation:

The overexpression of the MyoD gene is required to promote the differentiation of muscle cells from fibroblasts in the culture medium. In consequence, MyoD expression is sufficient for the differentiation of fibroblasts to muscle cells

User Tjugg
by
4.2k points