Answer:
$4
Explanation:
Total consumer surplus is given by the difference between the willingness to pay of each customer to the actual price of a good.
Since Avery is only willing to pay $10 and the pizza costs $12, Avery will not buy a pizza and should not be considered for consumer surplus.
Since Pia is willing to pay $13, and Sylvio is willing to pay $15, consumer surplus is:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e29c7/e29c7bc3232a12db4a0e3dad636ef4f1dc1f2694" alt="S = (\$13-\$12)+(\$15-\$12)\\S=\$4"
When the price of pizza is $12, a consumer surplus of $4 is achieved.