149k views
2 votes
Were the colonists justified in their rebellion against England? If you had been there, would you have sided with the colonial elite (who wanted to maintain status quo) or with the radicals? Why?

2 Answers

4 votes

Final answer:

The question of whether the colonists were justified in their rebellion against England is complex, with varying interpretations among historians. Factors such as grievances, peaceful attempts at resolution, and desire for self-governance influenced the decision to rebel. If I had been there, I would have sided with the colonists seeking independence, as they had legitimate grievances and their attempts at peaceful resolution had been ignored.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question of whether the colonists were justified in their rebellion against England is a complex one with varying interpretations among historians. Some argue that the Revolution was primarily a colonial rebellion seeking independence from Britain, while others see it as a violent social upheaval driven by a class conflict for greater democracy and equality. Factors such as the colonists' grievances, their attempts at peaceful resolution through petitioning, and the desire for self-governance influenced their decision to rebel.

If I had been there, I would have sided with the colonists seeking independence. The colonists had legitimate grievances against British rule, including taxation without representation and the denial of basic rights. Additionally, their attempts to seek redress through peaceful means had been met with indifference and oppression. Joining the rebellion would have been a way to fight for the rights of ordinary people and the establishment of a more democratic society.

User Rodney Quillo
by
4.5k points
0 votes

Answer:

The rebellion against England was justified by the taxes (creation or increasing of them), and laws that served more for England to obtain profit than the Colonists. These misunderstandings created the motif for the revolution. However, more than just a rebellion against taxes and laws, the American Revolution was in favor of freedom. Many of those colonists came to America to find a place to live and thrive, without the regulation of England.

If I was a colonist, I think that I would enlist to radicals, because these taxes and laws, of course, would affect my finances, and soon or later, it would cause a crisis.

Step-by-step explanation:

User Firanolfind
by
3.6k points