403,963 views
2 votes
2 votes
Read this claim and counterclaim.

Claim: Students should sell candy to raise money for the class trip.

Counterclaim: Students should sell fruit instead of candy because it is healthier.

Which evidence best addresses the counterclaim?

quotations from children who like candy bars
research that fruit has the same amount of sugar as candy
a book about how to make candy at home
facts showing candy is less expensive than fruit

User Haytem BrB
by
2.9k points

2 Answers

19 votes
19 votes
Will make a sandwich.

Not sure what kind but will make sandwiches
User Tillerstarr
by
3.2k points
21 votes
21 votes

Answer:

"The correct answer is B. Research that fruit has the same amount of sugar as candy"

Step-by-step explanation:

"The purpose of addressing a counterclaim is to provide evidence or reasons to disprove the counterclaim and in this way support the main claim. This implies to address the counterclaim it is necessary to show how selling fruit instead of candy is not healthy, as the counterclaim states fruit is better "because it is healthier".

According to this, the best evidence to do this is "Research that fruit has the same amount of sugar as candy" because this disproves the counterclaim by showing the amount of sugar in both elements is similar which shows fruit is not healthier than candy and therefore selling candy is the best option."

User TheWook
by
2.9k points