81.8k views
5 votes
"We ought to stop at a red light, even if no cars are coming and I could get to my destination that much sooner." Identify the ethical approach that follows this line of thought.

2 Answers

1 vote

Final answer:

The ethical approach of stopping at a red light despite no immediate consequence is likely rooted in deontological ethics or rule utilitarianism, with the latter permitting exceptions for greater overall utility, such as during emergencies. The trolley problem illustrates the conflict between these approaches, as utilitarianism would prioritize greater good outcomes while deontology would emphasize rule adherence.

Step-by-step explanation:

The ethical approach that follows the line of thought that 'We ought to stop at a red light, even if no cars are coming and I could get to my destination that much sooner', is likely rooted either in deontological ethics, which focuses on following rules and duties, or in rule utilitarianism (RU), which seeks the greatest good for the greatest number by adhering to rules that, in general, maximize utility.

In a situation where there is a pregnant woman in immediate need of medical assistance, rule utilitarianism might support breaking a traffic law by driving through a red light if doing so would result in a greater overall utility, such as safely delivering the woman to the hospital and possibly saving two lives.

When examining the trolley problem, individuals must make decisions that weigh the moral implications of their potential actions, which often align with utilitarian principles when opting to save the greater number of individuals. Contrastingly, a deontological perspective might prioritize the adherence to moral rules, such as not taking a direct action that results in harm.

User Andrew Goodnough
by
5.9k points
5 votes

Answer:

The Deontological ethics

Step-by-step explanation:

Deontology, in contemporary moral philosophy, is one of the normative theories according to which choices are morally necessary, forbidden or permitted. Therefore it is included among the moral theories that guide our choices about what should be done. Deontological ethics is commonly contrasted with consequentialism and the ethics of virtue. In this terminology, the action is more important than the consequences

User Tal Humy
by
6.9k points