138k views
2 votes
Explain what Nick means when he says, "Dishonesty in a woman is a thing you never blame deeply." The Great Gatsby

User TalesM
by
3.6k points

2 Answers

2 votes

Final answer:

Nick Carraway's remark on dishonesty in women reflects the gender biases of the 1920s, indicating a societal tendency to not harshly judge women's dishonesty, revealing both personal biases and cultural prejudices of the time as depicted in F. Scott Fitzgerald's work.

Step-by-step explanation:

When Nick Carraway says, "Dishonesty in a woman is a thing you never blame deeply," he is reflecting on the gender attitudes of the 1920s, expressed throughout F. Scott Fitzgerald's work. This comment suggests that Nick, and perhaps society at the time, tends to view women's dishonesty as less severe or blameworthy than that of men, due to underlying chauvinistic attitudes.

Nick's unreliable narration and superficial judgment of female characters are consistent themes across Fitzgerald's literature, highlighting the complexities and limitations of social perceptions during the Jazz Age.

This viewpoint can be seen as an indicator of the social inequality and the different standards that men and women faced. The era's patriarchal society often imposed less responsibility on women, paradoxically excusing certain behaviors while also marginalizing and limiting women's roles.

Therefore, Nick's statement is steeped in the contemporary societal context, revealing both his personal bias and the broader cultural prejudices.

Fitzgerald's characters, as seen through the eyes of a flawed narrator like Nick, are complex figures shaped by their societal circumstances. They reflect the era's tensions between wealth and morality, and the different expectations placed on men and women.

Nick's commentary on dishonesty is thus reflective of the intriguing, misguided, and often contradictory attitudes of the time.

User Arivaldo
by
3.9k points
5 votes

Answer:

Nick makes a statement about his relationship, or rather, romantic affair, with Jordan Baker. He informs the reader that he discovered Jordan cheated on her first golf tournament to win the first prize a long time ago, and that this explains exactly what she was about: dishonesty.

He did, however, have an affair with her and tells the reader that her dishonesty didn't bother him.

I believe Nick's statement perfectly describes his inner conflict regarding Jordan. His indifference to the fact that she was "incurably dishonest" (page 58, line 28) explains why he made that remark, in my opinion.

User Artur Grigio
by
4.6k points