74.9k views
1 vote
Describe how Thoreau uses personal examples to help structure his essay 'Resistance to Civil

Government." Then evaluate the effectiveness of his use of personal examples
by determining how clear,
Be sure to use specific
convincing, and engaging they help to make the overall points in the essay.
details from the text to support your ideas.

User Wrosecrans
by
5.8k points

2 Answers

4 votes

Henry David Thoreau structures his essay 'Resistance to Civil Government' with personal examples like his life at Walden Pond and his tax resistance, which clarify and support his arguments on individual freedom and civil disobedience. Alex Jones' essay analysis highlights the clarity, conviction, and engaging power of Thoreau's examples, and emphasizes the ongoing influence of Thoreau's ideas on personal freedom.

In his essay 'Resistance to Civil Government,' Henry David Thoreau uses personal examples, such as his decision to live at Walden Pond and his refusal to pay the poll tax, to structure his essay and exemplify his arguments for individual freedom and civil disobedience. These personal anecdotes serve as concrete instances where Thoreau put his philosophical stances into real-world practice.

Through detailing his daily activities at Walden and his willful imprisonment, Thoreau provides a clear and engaging illustration of how simplicity and principled choices represent a form of resistance against societal and governmental encroachments. His account of firsthand experiences lends credence and passion to his calls for nonviolent protest against injustice, thereby convincing the reader of the merits and practicability of living a life grounded in deeply held beliefs.

In Alex Jones' analysis 'The Two Freedoms of Henry David Thoreau,' the effectiveness of Thoreau's personal examples is recognized. Jones suggests that such vivid depictions of simple, intentional living not only clarify the concept of self-reliance but also resonate with audiences and inspire them to reconsider their own lives and actions in light of these two freedoms. Jones concludes by reiterating the lasting impact of Thoreau's ideologies and the influence they continue to exert on people worldwide.

User Jonatan Anauati
by
5.3k points
3 votes

Answer:

Thoreauau's personal experiences help give a sense of realisticness to what he's writing within his essay. The idea of resisting the government, being above whichever laws, seems irrational and bogus before taking the time to read this essay and while obviously there's still plenty of reason to confine to the government's wishes, his essay offers a outside input to the reasons in why you shouldn't- not because he feels as if he's immune to law, or above authority- but because he feels as current politicans and laws aren't as honorable as they are made out to be. With his personal experience he expresses that even through his time in jail, the law only confined his body and mind and alongside that with his wanting to conform to societal views however not finding them honorable makes for a convincing and engaging read, it's food for thought on the current laws we're all abiding by at this moment.

Step-by-step explanation:

User Alberto Gaona
by
5.6k points