61.3k views
6 votes
Which speech made a stronger use of the appeal to reason? Write two paragraphs that compare and contrast both speeches in terms of their appeals to reason.

Provide specific examples from the text to support your point. Use proper spelling and grammar.

User Fruggiero
by
3.7k points

1 Answer

6 votes

Final answer:

Speech A makes a stronger use of analogy as an appeal to reason, while Speech B relies more on cause and effect reasoning.

Step-by-step explanation:

When comparing the speeches in terms of their appeal to reason, we can look at the use of logical reasoning, evidence, and rational arguments to support their claims.

In Speech A, the speaker employs analogy as a reasoning strategy to make a stronger appeal to reason. They compare the situation at hand to a similar situation that the audience can relate to, in order to help them understand the argument. For example, the speaker says, 'Just as a ship needs a captain to steer it in the right direction, our country needs a strong leader to guide us through these challenging times.'

In contrast, Speech B relies more on cause and effect reasoning to make its appeal to reason. The speaker presents a series of cause and effect relationships to support their argument. For instance, they state, 'If we continue to ignore the environmental crisis, we will face irreversible damage to our planet and the well-being of future generations.'

User Robottinosino
by
3.4k points