Question

Writing an Argumentative Essay about the tradition confirmation

Answer 1

Crafting an argumentative essay on confirmation tradition involves developing a clear thesis, using researched evidence, addressing counterarguments thoroughly, and demonstrating the topic's significance through cause-and-effect reasoning.

Step-by-step explanation:

When writing an argumentative essay about the tradition of confirmation, it is essential to craft a thesis statement that posits a clear argument which others may contest. Take into account the advice given to Lily Tran in her first-year composition class, where she integrates researched evidence, appeals, and ethos to construct a persuasive and logical argument around traditional religious ceremonies. Understanding the recursive nature of the writing process is crucial, as it allows continual improvements and refinement of your paper. Responding robustly to counterarguments strengthens your credibility and shows a deep understanding of the topic.

For example, if discussing the contradiction between Geats' appearance and their actions within a literary text, a well-supported argument must provide evidence of how this impacts the broader context of the warrior kingdom. Similarly, an argument about the ceremony of confirmation would need to address both the historical significance and contemporary perspectives, acknowledging alternative viewpoints with substantial rebuttals. In essence, a successful argumentative essay on this topic should explore the meaning behind the tradition, its relevance in modern society, and engage with different interpretations and viewpoints.

Answer 2

A distinct difference between the Catholic Church and other Christian denominations, aside from the Eucharist, is the Sacrament of Confirmation. In it, God seals us with a mark of His divine protection, God gives us a disposition for His Grace, and we assign ourselves to a vocation to serve His Church (CCC, 1121).

Catholics often associate Confirmation with the same symbols of the Holy Spirit—fire, a wax seal, and holy oil—to acknowledge the Holy Spirit’s descending down on the recipients and giving them God’s Grace and protection. Catholics often use the symbol of fire to reference the New Testament when the Apostles receive the Holy Spirit at Pentecost in Acts 2:1-4:

“1When the time for Pentecost was fulfilled, they were all in one place together.

2And suddenly there came from the sky a noise…show more content…

Furthermore, a wax seal is often used to portray an indelible mark on the soul. Confirmation is one of three Sacraments that places an indelible mark on the soul, along with Baptism and Holy Orders. Historically, masters or owners used a seal to mark their property or servants (CCC, 1295) In this, God claims us as His own with His seal upon our souls that cannot be washed away. Jesus also states in the New Testament that He is marked with His Father’s seal (Jn, 6:27). Lastly, Confirmation bears a large connection with oil. In the Sacrament, the bishop uses oil to anoint the recipient as a spiritual seal. This relates with the Old Testament in which it was used to anoint kings, heal people, and denote beauty and abundance (CCC, 1294).

Step-by-step explanation: