Why does the Elvenking say that news of the death of Smaug is "an ill wind that blows no one any good"? He is worried that the elves will not receive a fair portion of the treasure. He suspects that all

My account
Edit my Profile
Private messages
My favorites

Ask a Question
Questions
Unanswered
Tags
Categories
Ask a Question

asked Nov 10, 2023 54.6k views

25 votes

Why does the Elvenking say that news of the death of Smaug is "an ill wind that blows no one any good"?

He is worried that the elves will not receive a fair portion of the treasure.

He suspects that all will covet the treasure when they hear that it lies unguarded.

He fears that the smell of the dead dragon will make the elves and the men sick.