Question

One of the criticisms raised against Utilitarianism is that the utilitarian standard sometimes conflicts with justice, meaning that some particular act might be right according to the utilitarian standard while at the same time being unjust. T or F

Answer 1

True

Step-by-step explanation:

Utilitarianism only focuses on that which creates the most "good" in the long run. It does not take into account the intention of the action. If a man saves a drowning baby but the baby later turns out to be none other than Adolf Hitler, saving his life creates more harm than good and is wrong according to utilitarian standards. However, according to most justice standards, it would be incorrect and unjust to let the baby drown as it is only a baby at the time and therfore innocent.