Answer:
The answer is Tonya's phone had the greater initial trade-in value.
Leo's phone decreases at an average rate slower than the trade in value of Tonya's phone.
Explanation:
Given
Tonya

Leo




Solving (a): The phone with greater initial value
The initial value is when x = 0. So, we have:




From Leo's table

By comparison;

i.e.

So: Tonya's had the greater initial trade-in value
Solving (b): The phone with lesser rate
An exponential function is:

Where:

For Tonya

For Leo, we have:


So, the equation becomes:

and

Solving
, we have:



becomes

Divide both sides by 480

Take square roots

-- Leo's rate
By comparison; Leo's rate is slower i.e. 0.87 < 0.88